Page Impressions Ltd Blogcetera: Does Searle’s Chinese Room argument establish that the mind is not a computer program?

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Does Searle’s Chinese Room argument establish that the mind is not a computer program?


I recently looked at the case for artificial intelligence and I revisited the arguments laid out by John R Searle in his argument that so called strong artificial intelligence cannot evolve from a computer program.  Using the Chinese Room (CR) argument advanced by John R Searle, I examine whether his contention that the mind is not a computer program is true in the context of what constitutes artificial intelligence (AI) and thus the computational theory of the mind is false.  In order to do this I will establish the agreed basis of artificial intelligence, outline the Turing Test for evaluating machine intelligence, describe the CR thought experiment and then evaluate the Seale’s principle claim that the CR experiment is merely a syntactic process requiring no semantic understanding and demonstrating strong AI to be false.

In order to evaluate Searle’s CR argument we first need to have a clear understanding of artificial intelligence and in particular the form of AI, so-called ‘Strong AI’, at which Searle is directing his thought experiment.  Strong AI is the philosophical thesis that appropriately programmed computers have minds in exactly the same sense that we do.

During the 1950s, Alan Turing proposed a simple test to evaluate whether a machine is making an adequate simulation of the human mind.  The ‘Turing Test’ states that ‘if a computer can pass for a human in online chat, we should grant that it is intelligent’. 
This leads us to divide AI into four specific categories:-

                AI1         Computers are capable of thought;

                AI2         Only computers are capable of thought;

                AI3         A machine can think simply as a result of instantiating a computer program;

                AI4         Computer models are useful in the study of the mind.

Clearly AI4 is the weakest form of AI and is not considered to be particularly controversial. However, the AI argument builds from AI3 through to AI1 as the claims become stronger. Indeed if AI2 is true then we are all computers!  The combination of AI1 and AI3 suggest that a thinking machine is possible and all we need to do is write the appropriate program and run it to demonstrate a thinking machine (Wilkinson, 2005, pg 100). Strong AI of this form suggests that a suitably programmed computer can understand natural language and actually have other mental attributes similar to humans whose abilities they mimic. For this reason if the AI3 form of AI can be undermined the entire strong AI argument is invalid.  Consequently AI3 is the form of AI that Searle considers ‘strong AI’ and which his CR argument is intended to show to be false and hence the mind is not a computer.

Searle’s CR experiment is a thought experiment which imagines an English speaker who knows no Chinese, locked in a room full of boxes of Chinese symbols (the database) together with a book of instructions for manipulating the symbols (the program).  Imagine the people outside the room send in other Chinese symbols (data input) which, unknown to the person in the room are questions in Chinese.  By following the instruction book, the man is able to pass out Chinese symbols and answer the questions correctly (the output).  Searle contends that the man in the CR has actually passed the Turing Test for understanding Chinese without having to understand a word of Chinese.  Put simply the Searle argument may be sum up as follows:-

Premise 1.           If ‘strong AI’ is true, there exists a program for Chinese such that if any computing system runs that program, that system may be considered to understand Chinese;

Premise 2.           The program may be operated by anyone, without understanding Chinese;

Conclusion.         Therefore, ‘Strong AI’ is false (from premise 2).

Premise 2 conforms to the CR and as such the inevitable conclusion is that running a program does not constitute understanding.  Searle’s central claim is that the CR experiment shows that it is not possible for syntax to result in semantics.  Syntax in this context refers to the way in which the Chinese symbols are manipulated as opposed to semantics which relates to the meaning of the symbols.  Essentially the program is purely a syntactical symbol system which merely manipulates the symbols and entirely lacks semantic properties without any understanding of their meaning (Wilkinson, 2005, pg 105).

Before I consider the case against Searle’s CR experiment, it would be useful to describe the programming process.  For a process to be programmable, the process must be able to be constructed as an algorithm.  For a process to be algorithmic the following must apply:-

1.                   Every step is specifiable entirely without ambiguity;

2.                   At every step, there is no ambiguity about what the next step must be: no insight, inspiration or creativity is needed;

3.                   Provided each step is correctly executed, the procedure will produce the desired result in a finite number of steps.

All computers, whether based on traditional step-by-step von Neumann architecture or parallel processing, are programmed in an algorithmic manner (Wilkinson, 2005, pgs 100 - 101).  The key issue is the ability to ‘frame’ the question in an algorithmic format to enable the computer to work.  Searle considers the computer program based on the algorithmic formulation to be purely syntactic, therefore, unable to be semantic and hence computer programs cannot produce minds.  Searle’s contention may be shown as follows:-

Premise 1.           Programs are purely formal algorithmic processes (syntactic);

Premise 2.           Human minds have mental contents (semantics);

Premise 3.           Syntax by itself is neither constitutive of, nor sufficient for, semantic content;

Conclusion.         Therefore, programs by themselves are not constitutive or sufficient for minds.

Premise 3 supports the CR thought experiment.

Now there are a number of criticisms to Searle’s CR argument against Strong AI, however, they are essentially variants on the so-called ‘System Reply’.  Essentially the counter argument is that no single element should be considered as the ‘mind’ of the CR, and certainly the man at the centre running the process does not understand the Chinese language, but rather it is the whole system operating together that develops an understanding of Chinese and hence a semantic grasp of the Chinese symbols.  Searle replies that if the man in the room were to memorise the instruction book and the database of Chinese characters and become the entire system, he still would not be able to attach any meaning to the formal symbols even though he is now the entire system.

Others criticise the fact that the man in the room is deprived of any sensorimotor connection to the world and that these are vital missing factors.  Searle counters that the Chinese characters could be the outputs of a television camera and the outgoing symbols be the commands to a robotic arm. He now has a connection, but still no understanding.

Others suggest that the CR does not model the way the brain works as complex neural network.  Searle counters by applying Ned Block’s Chinese Gym thought experiment, whereby millions of people in a huge gym are connected to one another by walkie-talkie radios passing instructions to one another acting as individual neurons participating in a neural network.  On the other hand, the same issue regarding semantics applies in this case as well.  The Chinese Gym does not understand Chinese any more than the CR.
Daniel Dennett’s challenge to the CR is based on the issue of complexity.  He contends that Searle’s experiment is far too simple and that this is the reason for no apparent understanding being present within the system.  Dennett argues that with increasing complexity you will get unexpected results resulting in radical changes in behaviour known as emergent properties which only occur when a system is sufficiently complex.  Such radical changes in behaviour or properties of complex systems are common in the natural (Wilkinson, 2007, pg 113-114).  Consequently, Dennett argues that any system capable of conversing in Chinese would most likely be far more complex than the CR experiment and it would be difficult to say confidently that the computer system did not understand Chinese.  Searle contends that running increasing complex programs are no more than more complex algorithms and are just as syntactic as previously described and not capable of semantics however complex.  Whilst I agree that a complex computer program is just an assembly of multiple simple routines, increasing complexity often leads to increased computing capability and can result in unexpected capabilities and even outcomes.

In the same vein, the challenge posed by Patricia and Paul Churchland suggests that the issue is one of interpretation and speed, in that the CR experiment is operating at a very much slower speed than the brain operates and as such ‘understanding’ cannot be detected.  They use the analogy based on Maxwell’s theory of light being made up of electro-magnetic waves.  In their thought experiment, a man stands in a darkened room and waves a magnet up and down.  Although light is indeed made up of electro-magnetic waves, no light would be detected.  The man waving the magnet does not disprove Maxwell’s theory that light consists of electromagnetic waves.  The missing component is speed.  The Churchlands’ thought experiment slows down the waves to a range to which we humans no longer see them as light.  By trusting to our intuitions in the thought experiment, we falsely conclude that rapid waves cannot be light either.  Similarly, the Churchlands’ claim that Searle has slowed down the mental process to a range we humans no longer think of it as ‘understanding’.  Thus the Churchlands contend that the same applies to Seale’s experiment and that if we were to meet the man from the CR who seemed to converse intelligently in Chinese, but was really deploying millions of memorised rules in a fraction of a second, it is not so clear that we would deny he understood Chinese (Pinker, 1997, pgs 94-95).

In conclusion, in consideration of the narrow interpretation of Searle’s claim that the mind is not a computer program I would accept his argument to be valid and that the computer program itself does not ‘understand’ as we interpret that word.  I found Seale’s dismissal of the counter arguments to be reasonable, with exception of Dennett’s and Churchlands’ arguments. The Churchlands’ thought experiment it is based on a very simple premise and easy to understand and Dennett’s emergent properties argument compelling.  Speed and complexity could be key factors in strong AI.  What is undoubtedly true is that the ‘Turing Test’ is no longer a sufficiently subtle evaluation of artificial intelligence.  Progresses in computing have advanced to a stage whereby it is entirely possible to converse with a computer and believe you are conversing with a human being.  The key issue in achieving a true computer ‘mind’ comes back to the framing issue.  This relates to the ability to program algorithmically beyond the essentially mathematical and logical tasks to consider such areas as intuition, belief or even love.  These functions of the mind are frequently considered irrational and illogical, but they are what make us human. The ability or functionality to program ‘illogically’ is probably beyond algorithmic programming of digital computers as we know them today.  Equally Searle’s argument hinges on our understanding of the semantics of language.  What do we mean by ‘understanding’ or ‘meaning’?  Or finally, is it the limitation of English as a language which is unable to provide an adequate explanation of differences and similarities between the mind and artificial intelligence?  Regardless, Searle’s valid dismissal of strong AI will not slow the pace of computing development and the likely move from the physical limitations of silicon-based computer architectures to bio-computers which utilise biologically derived molecules to perform computational processes.  The future of ‘strong AI’ probably lies in the rapid development, dare I say growth, of such bio-computers!

References
Wilkinson, RJ (2007) ‘Chapter 3 Monism (Conclusion) and Artificial Intelligence (Beginning), Robert Wilkinson Minds and Bodies, 2007, Open University Press.
Pinker, S (1997), Chapter 2, ‘Thinking Machines’, Steven Pinker, How the Mind Works, W.W.Norton & Company Ltd., 10 Coptic Street, London. WC1A 1PU

Copyright© John Tomany 2012

11 comments:

John said...

nike huarache
tory burch sale
nike air max
ray ban outlet
abercrombie and fitch
ralph lauren uk
canada goose outlet
coach factory outlet
uggs outlet
cheap oakley sunglasses
coach outlet
air jordan retro
canada goose jackets
tods outlet
coach outlet store online
uggs boots
oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet clearance
canada goose outlet
jordans for sale
pandora jewelry
ugg outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
michael kors outlet
ralph lauren outlet
lebron 12
canada goose outlet
louis vuitton outlet
canada goose outlet
20151202yuanyuan

Unknown said...

rumah di jual di foresta bsd city jual rumah murah di bsd rumah di bsd rumah dijual nusa loka bsd harga rumah di gading serpong sektor 1b dijual rumah murah di serpong jual rumah gading serpong sektor 1g harga rumah bsd kencana loka rumah dijual di bsd tangerang rumah murah di serpong 2012 rumah di bsd icon sewa apartemen murah di jakarta utara apartemen di jakarta timur apartemen di jakarta apartemen murah jakarta jual apartemen murah di jakarta timur sewa apartemen harian jakarta apartemen murah di jakarta barat sewa apartemen murah di jakarta barat sewa apartemen jakarta barat murah

Unknown said...

Toko Baju Online Rumah Disewa Alam Sutera Tas Dompet Toko Baju Online Grosir Tas Batam Cream Pemutih Selan Rumah Dijual Di Tam Gambar Tas Harga Tas Murah Harga Sewa Rumah Alam Sutera Kosmetik Pencerah Wajah Krim Pemutih Selang Cream Pemutih Wajah Jual Rumah Bsd 500 Tas Grosir Properti Apartemen Belanja Tas Tas Tas Import Tas Fashion Grosir Tas Import B

Unknown said...

Rumah Dijual Di Delatinos Dijual Rumah Di Gad Model Pagar Besi Minimalis Mobil Truk Gandeng Butik Baju Murah Tanah Dijual Di Bsd City Grosir Tas Fashion Online Rumah Dijual Serpong Jual Rumah Di Bsd 2 Genteng Banyuwangi Permainan Mobil Truk Tas Tas Import Batako Press Desain Rumah Kost Minimalis Desain Ruko Genteng Kaca Genteng M Class Jual Karbon Aktif Arsitektur Klasik

oakleyses said...

burberry outlet online,burberry,burberry outlet,burberry handbags,burberry factory outlet,burberry sale, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors outlet,michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet online,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors, tiffany and co jewelry,tiffany and co outlet,tiffany and co,tiffany's,tiffanys,tiffany co,tiffany jewelry, rolex watches,rolex,watches for men,watches for women,omega watches,replica watches,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex, tiffany and co jewelry,tiffany and co outlet,tiffany and co,tiffany's,tiffanys,tiffany co,tiffany jewelry, oakley sunglasses, longchamp handbags,longchamp,longchamp outlet,longchamp bags,long champ, uggs, nike free,free running,nike free run,nike free 5.0,free running 2,nike running shoes,nike free trainer,nike free trainer 5.0,free runs,free run 5.0, michael kors outlet store,michael kors outlet,michael kors outlet online,michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors, tory burch outlet,tory burch,tory burch handbags,tory burch shoes,tory burch sale,toryburch,tory burch sandals,toryburch.com,tory burch flip flops, prada handbags,prada,prada sunglasses,prada shoes,prada outlet,prada bags, kate spade outlet,kate spade,katespade,kate spade handbags, louis vuitton handbags,vuitton handbags,louis vuitton bags,louis vuitton purses, nike shoes,nike outlet,nike factory,nike store,nike factory outlet,nike outlet store,cheap nike shoes,nike sneakers, uggs outlet, louis vuitton outlet online,louis vuitton,louis vuitton outlet,louisvuitton.com,authentic louis vuitton,louis vuitton factory outlet,cheap louis vuitton, chanel handbags,chanel bags,chanel sunglasses,chanel purses,chanel outlet, louis vuitton outlet,louis vuitton outlet online,louis vuitton,louisvuitton.com,authentic louis vuitton,louis vuitton factory outlet,cheap louis vuitton, longchamp,longchamp handbags,longchamp outlet,longchamp bags,long champ

oakleyses said...

kate spade handbags,kate spade,kate spade outlet,katespade, nike free,free run,nike free run,nike free pas cher,nike free run pas cher,nike free france, nike air max,air max,air max pas cher,air max one,air max 90,air max france, hollister,abercrombie,abercrombie fitch,hollister france,hollister pas cher,abercrombie and fitch,hollister pas cher, timberland pas cher, true religion, nike air max, ralph lauren,ralph lauren uk,ralph lauren outlet,polo ralph lauren outlet, air force,nike air force,air force 1,air force one,nike air force 1,nike air force one,air force one nike, mulberry,mulberry handbags,mulberry outlet,mulberry bags,mulberry uk, nike air max, michael kors,sac michael kors,michael kors pas cher,sac michael kors pas cher,michael kors france, oakley pas cher,oakley,oakley soldes,lunette oakley pas cher,oakley france, michael kors, vans,vans pas cher,vans soldes, lululemon,lululemon canada,lululemon outlet canada,lululemon outlet online, true religion, longchamp,sac longchamp,longchamps,longchamp pas cher,sac longchamp pas cher,longchamp pliage,longchamp soldes,sac longchamps,longchamp france, hogan,hogan outlet,scarpe hogan,hogan sito ufficiale,hogan interactive, nike free run, air max,nike air max,air max pas cher,air max one,air max 90,air max france, tn pas cher,nike tn,nike tn pas cher,nike tn requin,tn requin,tn requin pas cher, coach outlet,coach factory outlet,coach outlet store,coach factory,coach outlet store online,coach factory online,coach factory outlet online,coach outlet online, north face, michael kors,michael kors uk,michael kors handbags,michael kors bags, nike roshe uk, coach outlet store online,coach outlet store,coach outlet, louboutin,chaussure louboutin,louboutin pas cher,chaussures louboutin,chaussure louboutin pas cher,louboutin france, true religion, michael kors canada, nike blazer

oakleyses said...

ugg boots,uggs,ugg,ugg boots uk,ugg uk, vans scarpe, montre pas cher, karen millen dresses, hollister,hollister canada,abercrombie and fitch,abercrombie,abercrombie and,abercrombie kids,af, swarovski jewelry, canada goose outlet, barbour,barbour jackets,leather jackets,barbour sale,barbour outlet,barbour uk,barbour coats,barbour clothing, converse, louis vuitton,louis vuitton canada,louis vuitton outlet,louis vuitton outlet online, pandora jewelry,pandora charms,pandora bracelet,pandora bracelets,pandora rings,pandora jewelry store locator,pandora charm,pandora charms clearance,pandora store,pandora jewelry outlet store,pandora jewelry sale online, rolex watches,replica watches,omega watches,rolex watches for sale,replica watches uk,fake rolex, moncler,moncler outlet,moncler sito ufficiale, moncler outlet, lancel, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, canada goose outlet, canada goose outlet, ugg pas cher, pandora jewelry, barbour, louis vuitton,borse louis vuitton,louis vuitton sito ufficiale,louis vuitton outlet, canada goose, ugg,ugg australia,uggs,ugg pas cher,ugg soldes,bottes ugg,bottes ugg pas cher, moncler jackets, gucci, louis vuitton,sac louis vuitton,louis vuitton pas cher,sac louis vuitton pas cher,louis vuitton france, doke & gabbana, juicy couture outlet, sac louis vuitton,louis vuitton,louis vuitton pas cher,sac louis vuitton pas cher,louis vuitton france, wedding dresses,wedding dress,dresses for wedding,bride dresses,dresses for weddings,wedding dresses uk,cheap wedding dresses,vintage wedding dresses,monsoon wedding dresses,lace wedding dresses,wedding dresses for older brides,wedding dresses 2014, coach outlet,coach factory,coach factory outlet,coach outlet store,coach outlet store online,coach factory online,coach factory outlet online,coach outlet online, juicy couture, moncler

Anonymous said...

ninest123 16.02
oakley sunglasses, polo ralph lauren outlet, prada handbags, oakley sunglasses, louboutin, michael kors outlet, tiffany jewelry, ray ban sunglasses, ugg boots, ugg boots, louis vuitton, ugg boots, ray ban sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton, burberry outlet online, replica watches, replica watches, louis vuitton outlet, prada outlet, michael kors outlet, longchamp outlet, burberry, michael kors outlet, louboutin outlet, ray ban sunglasses, nike outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, ugg boots, gucci outlet, tory burch outlet, chanel handbags, uggs on sale, polo ralph lauren outlet, michael kors outlet, nike air max, michael kors, nike air max, louboutin shoes, louis vuitton, christian louboutin outlet, oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, tiffany and co, nike free, jordan shoes, longchamp, longchamp outlet, oakley sunglasses

Anonymous said...

louboutin pas cher, converse pas cher, true religion jeans, nike free, longchamp, true religion outlet, coach purses, nike trainers, burberry, coach outlet, air max, new balance pas cher, replica handbags, true religion jeans, nike roshe run, nike roshe, north face, ralph lauren pas cher, sac guess, mulberry, true religion jeans, timberland, michael kors, tn pas cher, longchamp pas cher, ray ban pas cher, nike huarache, nike air max, north face, hermes, oakley pas cher, vans pas cher, hollister, ray ban uk, hollister pas cher, abercrombie and fitch, ralph lauren uk, nike blazer, michael kors, sac longchamp, nike free run uk, air force, lululemon, michael kors, air jordan pas cher, nike air max, lacoste pas cher, hogan, nike air max, michael kors, vanessa bruno

Anonymous said...

toms shoes, canada goose uk, sac louis vuitton pas cher, canada goose, hollister, barbour jackets, converse outlet, barbour, louis vuitton, bottes ugg, moncler, marc jacobs, louis vuitton, supra shoes, juicy couture outlet, moncler, moncler, montre pas cher, moncler, doke gabbana outlet, replica watches, ugg pas cher, louis vuitton, canada goose, karen millen, pandora jewelry, moncler, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, doudoune canada goose, coach outlet, pandora charms, swarovski crystal, links of london, pandora jewelry, canada goose, lancel, louis vuitton, wedding dresses, moncler, pandora charms, canada goose outlet, moncler, ugg boots uk, thomas sabo, canada goose outlet, juicy couture outlet, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, canada goose, swarovski, moncler outlet
ninest123 16.02

abo-bder said...


شركة تركيب ستائر بالرياض
شركة تركيب اثاث ايكيا بالرياض
شركة تركيب اثاث ايكيا بالرياض
تركيب ستائر بالرياض
شركة قص اشجار بالرياض
فني تركيب دش